Skip to main content

China: A Glass Mansion

By Abeer Sikder, Class of 2014


China is a very powerful, yet fragile state. It is powerful internationally, but fragile domestically – much like a glass mansion. It appears to be a magnificent and powerful structure. But one small crack, and the whole foundation can falter.
On the surface, China has been doing great in many ways since the mid-20th Century. Under Mao Zedong (1948-78), average annual growth was 6 percent. Even with low GDP, the domestic economy was actually stable overall. Furthermore, wealth became more equally distributed and corruption in many government sectors wasn’t as serious as it had been before. (I am speaking about the general economy and infrastructure throughout this period. Obviously, there were many scandals and horrible occurrences under Mao’s regime. Nonetheless, this is when China began to reemerge as a superpower in the 20th Century.)
Since 1978, average annual growth has been around 10 percent. China is the world’s second largest economy and holds the largest foreign reserves of any nation.
In comparison, the US has grown on average from 2 to 3 percent per year since its founding. However, the US is generally considered to be much more stable, as we have a political system with stronger foundations that our citizenry takes great pride in. We may criticize our leaders, but we love our republic. And Americans who become rich and powerful do so legitimately. (Well, this is often not true, but it’s very legitimate compared to China).
While China’s growth over the last 60 years has been spectacular and vastly improved the country in many ways, China’s political system is still marred. China’s fragility originates with its socioeconomic and political instability. The income gap is larger than that in the US. Of the top twenty most polluted cities in the world, sixteen are in China. Its workers suffer from a multitude of human rights abuses. Corruption is widespread in the Chinese government (much like Congress and the White House), and it can easily lead to the death of the Communist Party.
Even though it suffers from many internal conflicts, China continues growing and improves virtually every year – especially because of economic liberalization. China’s economic evolution has assisted the US economy and established a new balance of power that has, and will continue to, define the world.  Many politicians convince us that China is our opponent – we have to compete with them for jobs, better goods, economic dominance, etc. But we heavily rely on China and its even more prominent global position to stabilize the world. And its importance is not just significant to the US, but also to virtually every actor on the international stage. 

Here is a link to an four-part series called “China Rising” from Al-Jazeera. It emphasizes my point that China is a global superpower that faces many domestic conflicts:
And here is an opposing editorial by Fareed Zakaria from the Washington Post criticizing China’s superpower status:

Abeer Sikder is a junior McConnell Scholar at the University of Louisville.  He is studying economics, political science and finance.